Someone wrote on my blog a
while ago and asked a question that I believe is worth exploring. “I’m 17 years
old and I’m curious about this career.
Can someone tell me more about this?
Is this a good career as in salary and job options?” The fact that this individual is asking these
questions means that they are probably far ahead of the curve as far as
thinking about the future (or at least ahead of me at 17). These are great questions to ask about any
career, and I will attempt to broadly answer some of these questions.
For those who like to skip the
heavy reading, here is my brief summary: Being an aircraft mechanic can be
a very fulfilling and financially rewarding career choice for those who enjoy
learning and working with their hands. The job field is highly cyclical
and the best opportunities will usually go to those who either reside in major
metropolitan areas or are willing to be geographically mobile. It also
rewards those with specialized skill sets and applicable experience and
training. Is that succinct enough? Now let me tease that out into a mere 4,000
words.
Here is a brief list of questions to ask
yourself before you go to A&P school:
- Do you enjoy working with your hands?
- Are you okay with moving and/or living in a major metro area to further your career?
- Are you okay with giving up marijuana (legal or not) in order to work in this field? - this issue came up a surprising number of times while I was in A&P school
- Are you willing to work odd shifts and hours (nights, weekends, holidays, overtime)? If not, the career options are much more limited. The nature of our business (very high fixed costs), makes downtime very expensive.
- Are you okay with earning a wage in the $50,000-80,000 range, and likely starting out lower than that?
- Are you okay with a career that will likely require you to change employers multiple times?
- Are you okay with a career that requires you to pay your dues and build your experience before you really launch?
To me, the most pressing question is whether or not you will
enjoy your chosen career field. I will
attempt to help you address that question first. If you are the kind of person who enjoys
tinkering with thing and learning about how they work (be it 4x4’s, cars, four
wheelers, paintball guns, R/C cars, model airplanes, etc), you will probably
enjoy this career field. It doesn’t take
a mechanical genius to make a good mechanic (though it certainly doesn’t hurt)
because I believe the most important characteristic of a good mechanic is sound
judgment. If you feel confident enough
to change your own oil and basic repairs and maintenance on your cars and house
(change out a kitchen faucet, assemble an IKEA shelf –{ on further consideration,
strike that from the record, if you can do that first try you are in the
mechanical genius pool}, unclog a sink trap, change spark plugs and wires) and
don’t mind doing it yourself, you will be able to figure out the mechanical
part of the job. I would not recommend
this job if you don’t know what a Vise-Grip is, or how to use it. I had classmates who were at that level, and
while one of them did make through and is a mechanic, most washed out of the
program because the learning curve was too steep for them. If you enjoy working with your hands this
career may be a good option for you. One
other subject that I feel compelled to touch on is marijuana or any other recreational
drug usage. While cultural attitudes
towards have shifted, especially towards marijuana, this is not the career for
you if you want to enjoy recreational marijuana. Pretty much every job that requires an
aircraft mechanic’s license will be in a safety sensitive position that will
require pre-employment, post-accident and random drug screenings. Let me tell you that there is very little
(read: none) momentum for removing marijuana from the DOT’s of banned
substances (https://www.transportation.gov/odapc/medical-marijuana-notice). It is basically a one strike and you are out,
probably forever, if you fail a drug screening.
A prospective employer is required to find out if you have ever failed
or declined a drug test for a previous safety sensitive position. If you aren’t okay with that, this is not the
career field for you.
If you still feel like aviation maintenance might be a good
fit for you, a good place to start learning about careers in aircraft
maintenance is the Bureau of Labor and Statistics' website (https://www.bls.gov/ooh/installation-maintenance-and-repair/aircraft-and-avionics-equipment-mechanics-and-technicians.htm).
It contains a wealth of information about job duties, career
opportunities and outlooks, and salary information (including geographic
specific information - look under state and area data). It has a lot of
very valuable data and can be a very useful tool in negotiating your salary and
benefits.
Aircraft maintenance is a very
unique career field that has some unusual advantages and drawbacks. The
first thing to know about the field of aviation maintenance is that it is a
very cyclical, unstable industry. If you are hoping to hire on somewhere
and work there for the rest of your life, this is probably not going to be the
career for you (and there are less and less other careers where staying in one
place is even a possibility). The vast majority of aircraft mechanics
that I know have worked for multiple employers in multiple geographical
locations throughout their career. This fact is predominately a function
of the nature of the aircraft business (cyclical, heavily dependent on
disposable income, bankruptcies and mergers as standard business practices),
and particularly the airline business (where a large portion of the jobs are).
Aircraft maintenance is also a very geographically mobile field (which
may be a plus to some, and a huge drawback to others). If you have dreams
of returning to/remaining in the small town where you grew up or simply want to
remain geographically fixed somewhere outside of a major metro area, this will
probably be a tough career field. If you are willing /excited to be
geographically mobile and/or want to live in a major metro area, a job position
of some kind will pretty much always be available to you. In general, aircraft maintenance is a pretty
solid career in return for a two year, mostly technical education.
The basic
credential within the industry is the Airframe and Powerplant (hereafter
referred to as an A&P) license, obtained through testing with the FAA. Obtaining an A&P requires passing 6
separate tests. There 3 multiple choice
written tests that require a minimum score of 70% over, respectively, airframe,
powerplant, and general curriculum.
There are also 3 “Oral and Practical” tests that will require the
candidate to answer questions and perform practical tasks correctly in different
subject areas related to those three categories.
There are two basic ways to earn the
right to test for an A&P: Attend a
part 147 school (so named because that is the section of federal government law
that governs A&P schools), or accumulate 4,800 hours of experience working
on airplanes in some capacity (in the military, as an apprentice, or in a
“repair station” {the license is owned by the company rather than the
individual so they don’t have to hire A&P’s}).
Gaining
your A&P through a part 147 school has advantages and drawbacks. Some of the advantages are the availability
of an accredited degree at many institutions, the availability of financial aid
(again, typically only at accredited institutions), a broad range of exposure
(which will help you figure out what you might like/dislike/be good at and
about the career and specific niches in it), good guidance and preparation for
studying for and passing the FAA A&P tests, and a network to help you with
future job hunts. Many schools also
offer placement assistance to help you find a job. Some schools can be completed in as little as
a year (full-time, no summer break), though two is more common (it took me 3
years because of one class that wasn’t offered till my final semester). The downsides are that you will need to find
a way to pay for classes (though at accredited institutions, student loans,
scholarships, and grants are widely available – talk to the admissions
department at your target school to find out more) and not all of the training
that you gain will be useful. The
academic part of the schooling is not very rigorous at most of the schools I
have been around (though there are exceptions to that). In general, if you graduated high school or
got your GED you should have no problem with the academics. The education and career opportunities
offered by different schools vary tremendously. Oftentimes schools will
employ very good teachers alongside very poor teachers, and too often (in my
experience), the quality of the education is heavily dependent on the level of
each student's engagement (I.E. If you are interested, ask questions and apply
yourself, you will receive a good education, otherwise not). I had a
number of classmates who skated through classes with good grades but did not
apply themselves, got to the end of the program, and realized that they hadn't
really learned very much and were unable to pass the tests required to receive
their Airframe and Powerplant License.
In talking with others in my industry who have come from different
schools, it seems like, generally speaking,
the private schools do a much better job with career support
post-education (bringing in employers, interview coaching, resume building,
etc.). I know that my (public) school
had support as far as interview and resume prep, but there was little to no
industry engagement. Most A&P
programs offer you the opportunity to take a few general education classes (my
program required 6 classes or 18 credits) and add an associate’s degree in
addition to the certificate that allows you to take the A&P test. My own take on that is that I would generally
encourage that as long as you understand that it will probably make little to
no difference in pay or opportunities at the beginning of your career, but it
will mean more as you move up through the ranks (management within the industry
often comes a maintenance background, so it is likely you will have opportunity
to move in that direction so if you are so gifted and inclined) and
particularly if you decide to pursue further education (as I did by obtaining a
bachelor’s degree). As you evaluate
schools, I would encourage you to visit them and try to talk to both students
and professors. If you happen to know
someone or can connect to someone via Linkedin or Facebook who has graduated
from the program, ask them what their experience was like. Did they feel like they were well prepared to
enter the workforce? What professors did
they like, want to avoid? What
opportunities did they have coming out of school? How much did school cost? How did they pay for it? You can glean a lot from someone who has
recently trod the path you are looking to travel. You can find search the list of Part 147
mechanic schools here: http://av-info.faa.gov/MaintenanceSchool.asp
(beware that an organization may hold a part 147 ticket but not have an
operating school). The FAA also puts out
reports regarding the test scores and passing rates for each certificated school
here: https://www.faa.gov/data_research/aviation_data_statistics/test_statistics/
Scores and passing rate aren’t
everything, but you can get some kind of idea about how many graduates a
program is turning out and how prepared they are for the tests based on this
information. A large number of
candidates with generally high scores and passing rates is obviously a really
good sign.
The experience method can be a great
option for some people, though it generally doesn’t offer as broad an education
as school does and will require some pretty serious self-study in order to pass
the required FAA tests. The upside is
that you typically have a paid job (or at least don’t have to pay for school),
and the work experience you gain is obviously completely applicable (A&P
part 147 curriculum is in the process being updated, but some of it just won’t
be applicable to your work career).
Another downside is that even working full time, 4,800 hours is 2 ½ years, working part-time 10 hours a week
it would be over 9 years! You are
required to keep records of your hours and what you did during those hours, as
well as have it signed off by an A&P mechanic. The requirements may be found on the FAA
website (https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&sid=6d0c9eeb7fd01619d428ab2e585e5255&rgn=div5&view=text&node=14:2.0.1.1.4&idno=14#_top),
or you can call your local Flight Standards District Office (hereafter referred
to as the FSDO) (The FSDO locations/regions also can be found on the FAA
website) for guidance on what they would like to see. I must admit a complete ignorance on what is
required for those from a military background, but this link seemed to have
some really good information: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/gaining-ap-certification-wmilitary-experience-part-1-4-joe-williams.
Another certification within the industry that I will just
touch on briefly is the Inspection Authorization or “IA”. It is a certification only available to
A&P mechanics who have held their license for at least 2 years, been
engaged in maintenance during that time and who have passed a written (multiple
choice) test and an interview with their FAA representative. It allows the mechanic to “sign off” certain
maintenance tasks that a basic A&P is not allowed to. Many employers like to see their employees
pursue this and will offer financial incentives to do so. Some jobs (like my current one) require it as
a condition of employment.
The next
step after acquiring your A&P license is what I view as the most
challenging, and that is landing your first job and gaining your initial
experience. Getting hired is kind of
catch-22, especially for students coming out of a part 147 school. Most employers are reluctant to hire someone
with no experience but obviously there is no way to gain experience without
being hired. Breaking into the industry
is difficult, but there are opportunities.
I have few words of advice here:
Be persistent, utilize your network, talk to people face to face if at
all possible, over the phone as a last resort, and be willing to move if need
be. Do not expect to get an interview based solely on an online
application - this does happen, but rarely in my experience. If you don’t immediately find something, find
a way to stay engaged in aviation via volunteering or working an aviation job
outside of maintenance (line work, gate agent, etc.). Employers want to see any kind of experience,
and it will also be valuable to you from a learning standpoint. There aren’t really any shortcuts here that I
am aware of. You will need to pay your
dues from an employment standpoint.
Based on my own admittedly anecdotal experience and observing my classmates,
most of the time you will have to put in your time in a challenging work
environment before you can move on (or up) to one with better prospects. Most of the entry level positions pay poorly
(think $10-20 an hour depending on where you live), but most of them do at
least offer benefits. One word of
caution, it is difficult if not impossible to determine the ethical culture of
company prior to your employment, but there are a small minority of companies
that will engage in shady business practices and that will put pressure on you
as a mechanic to do things that are not ethical or safe. Not surprisingly this type of company will
typically struggle to hire and retain employees, so they will target hiring new
graduates because they won't know enough have enough options to avoid the
company. You need to be willing to look
to move on from that employer if you feel that is the situation. The most common entry level positions are in
general aviation (think small, piston driven airplanes), regional airlines, and
larger repair stations. You would be one
in a million if you start out at your dream job in this industry. Good companies will provide some pathway of
upward mobility as well as useful skills and training. Those are the kind of companies that you can
make a career at if you so choose. Most companies that are hiring fresh
graduates are understandably hesitant to make big investments in rookie
mechanics that may or may not stick. Try
to find out if the company that you are looking at working for offers any
training or certifications to their employees.
If you have a choice, I would recommend looking for places that work on
commonly used airframes that are still in production (i.e. Boeing 737). If you have wonderful experience on an
oddball aircraft it will not be as useful for your future career prospects if
you have to move on from your original employer.
I would segment the
industry roughly as follows (though I will undoubtedly miss some, some
cross-pollinate, etc.): Avionics, regional
airlines, major airlines, general aviation, domestic contract work, overseas
contract work, corporate aviation, manufacturing, large-scale
Maintenance/Repair/ Overhaul (MRO), helicopter, air medical, non-aviation (i.e.
wind farms and locomotives) and education.
Most often the easiest places to break into with no experience are MRO,
manufacturing, regional airlines, non-aviation, and general aviation. They will also typically offer lower starting
pay. Most typically do offer benefits
like retirement, health insurance, educational assistance, paid time off, etc.
Once you reach a baseline
level of experience (that 2-5 year mark) and higher level pay scale, employers
weigh heavily prior experience on the aircraft that you will be maintaining when
making hiring decisions. Employers also like to see the development of
useful skill-sets that are not necessarily aircraft specific.
The most important experience
in my estimation is electrical troubleshooting. Aircraft are rapidly
increasing in electrical complexity, and as those systems age, they require
more and more maintenance. Many of the components in electrical systems
run $10,000 and even more, so the cost for changing the wrong component, or
replacing a component when you actually have a wiring issue is really
high. Developing your electrical troubleshooting skills should be a
priority if you are interested in this career. Youtube is a great
resource for better understanding how to use a multi-meter for
troubleshooting and also understanding electrical theory.
Another skill-set that is growing in
importance is the field of composite repair. This tends to be much more
specialized and require more job-specific training to perform, but more and
more aircraft are going towards composite airframes in order to save weight and
prevent corrosion. As those airframes mature, they will require more
repairs.
There are a number of other specialties:
Avionics, sheet-metal repair, hydraulics, air conditioning, painting.
Adding any or all of these specialties to your resume will make you more
attractive to prospective employers. I kept a personal maintenance log
where I recorded what airframes I had worked on and what work I had performed
on them for my first couple of years in industry. This is especially
useful if you are working on a lot of different aircraft.
Once you reach that 2-5 year level of
experience, you will start to have a lot more job options within the industry,
and you will probably have a much better idea of what you would like to do/are
good at. The career progression for aviation maintenance is that you
typically will either develop a specialized skillset and pursue increasing
levels in that or else move into management. The management track typically
involves becoming a shift lead/supervisor, then director of maintenance.
There may be several more layers of management depending on the size and
structure of the company, but typically moving up in management means moving
more and more away from hands-on work towards paperwork and managing
people. The most important skills for management will be communication
and reading/interpreting data.
One more "skill" that I feel
compelled to touch on is judgment. The FAA licensure allows us to
exercise our judgment to determine what is, or is not, airworthy. Many
times the manufacturer will give you concrete data to tell you what is
airworthy or not (e.g. if a spark plug is worn to these dimensions it needs
replaced), but some times there will not be specific data related to what you
see or find (e.g. an air filter is extremely dirty but isn't due to be replaced
yet). When you are first starting out in the field you will need to be
cautious in exercising your judgment by checking what you think against other
mechanics and/or field representatives/tech support. Try to understand
the rationale behind the judgment rather than just getting a yes or no answer
so that you can develop your own judgment. Be aware that some mechanics
will be ready and willing to share, while others will be too
insecure/grumpy/inept to be of much use. Do not allow them to discourage
you. Everyone was new once, and being inexperienced and asking questions
does not make you stupid (though some insecure mechanics pretend that is the
case). Being inexperienced and not asking questions makes you
unsafe. Judgment is a skill that can be developed, and the best way to do
so is to gain experience. This is also one area where your prior
mechanical (non-aviation) experience can be a big advantage. I call this
my "farmer sense" or some people would call it a gut feeling.
Sometimes you just know something isn't right even though the book might not
tell you anything about it (my best illustration of this was that I noticed on
an air conditioning compressor that the pulleys of the compressor and the motor
did not align and that was why the belt was wearing out prematurely).
Don't ignore your gut feeling. If you have a sense that something isn't
right, investigate further. Be willing bring other people into the
equation. Even if your intuition is wrong, it is an opportunity to hone
your judgment, and you may save someone's life someday. My current
employer has an actual in-house campaign telling people to "work with a
questioning attitude". The stakes are too high to risk ignoring
something significant.
Ultimately I would recommend this
career to anyone who answered yes to the initial questions I posed . The number and quality of opportunities will
vary depending on the current economic conditions, but ultimately there will be
opportunity even as our industry transitions more and more to drone work vs.
piloted aircraft.
I will briefly share my own
educational and career journey and earnings to give a little snapshot of what a
career in this industry might look like.
I attended a
local community college in the Midwest. Some of my professors were
amazing, and some were simply cashing a paycheck. All of them were
willing (to varying degrees) to share what they knew with students who were
engaged. I also took general education classes (one per semester) in
order to finish with an associates' degree in Applied Science. I averaged
about 15 credits per semester, and I did little to no homework outside of class
time (save for my gen-Ed classes). It took me 3 years to finish up, and I
was pretty much able to get my education for free (thanks to the Pell Grant and
cheap tuition).
While I was
in school, I took advantage of a couple of opportunities to volunteer with
different teachers while they were working on aircraft. I gained valuable
experience and, in one case, even a future work reference (just f.y.i. most
schools will not allow their teachers to provide work references – my reference
was no longer teaching). Volunteer opportunities are excellent
opportunities to gain real-world experience as well as build your future job
network. There are often clubs that work on restoring warbirds or other
aircraft. Ask around at your local airport if you aren't aware of any
such opportunities. The aviation world is a very small community in most areas
of the country. This brings me to an important lesson: Network, network,
network, and never ever burn any bridges in aviation. Even if you will
never work that job ever again, oftentimes people you work with will wind up
other places, and if you leave a bad impression, your reputation will spread
within the aviation community, and that is not something you want to contend
with if/when you are job-searching.
I got my first job with a local
FBO (fixed base operator) in the Midwest, primarily doing corporate and general
aviation work. I heard about and was offered the job largely due to my
networking while I was in school. I started at around $12 an hour
(finished at basically the same range after 18 months)(a pay cut from my bus
driving job, but I knew I had to break into the business), but I did get
vacation and great benefits, including health insurance. The schedule was
great (weekdays 9-5), and we seldom had to work holidays or overtime.
Basically my only other option was to go to work for a small regional
airline where I would have made slightly more money and gotten travel benefits,
but given up my cushy schedule. It won't matter all that much how you
break into the industry, the important thing is simply that you do so. I
put in 18 months at that job, and it gave me a wide range of
experience/exposure as well as the opportunity to glean a lot of tribal
knowledge and confidence. I did a lot of grunt work (lubricating gear,
installing and removing interiors), but I always tried to pay attention when
people found/troubleshot problems. It was a great opportunity to learn
how to go about troubleshooting a wiring issue or what common problems were
with a PT6 engine.
While I was working that job, I
got the opportunity to go to work at a aircraft sheet metal repair shop
part-time. I was paid around $15 an hour, and again had an opportunity to
broaden my experience and exposure.
My next step was to cast a
broader geographical net because I knew that there just wasn't much for
aviation maintenance opportunity in my local area. I applied in several
different areas, including Alaska. I wound up accepting a job in Alaska
and moving from the Midwest up there (without any moving assistance outside of
them shipping my toolbox for me - very risky move had it not worked out).
It was a gamble on my part because I didn’t know much about my employer,
but it turned out to be a great move/fit for me. I started out around $22 an
hour up there, but quickly realized that I had taken a pay cut from the Midwest
because of the higher cost of living. On the plus side, I quickly moved
up the pay scale, and I finished making about $30 an hour just 2 years later.
This job gave me more specialty experience, and I also got the
opportunity to attend a factory Pratt & Whitney PT6 turbine engine school
(a widely used engine within the industry). I worked primarily on
turbo-props on evening and weekend shifts.
My most recent step was a move
into the air medical arena. I started working for a system operating both
fixed wing aircraft (my foot in the door) and helicopters, primarily working a
standard daytime work schedule (subject to change based on inspections).
I took a slight hourly pay cut, but I also left Alaska and saw my cost of
living plummet. Part of the reason that I pursued air-medical is that I
am hopeful that it will be a long-term career.
Air medical has traditionally
been less cyclical than GA, Business Aviation, or Airlines because it is not
heavily dependent on disposable income.
There is no such thing as a secure job in aviation (outside of possibly
government) and even my industry of choice faces risks from industry regulation
that may significantly impact the number of jobs available.
In summation,
I wouldn’t trade any of my experiences as an aircraft mechanic (though I would not want to repeat some
of them). I am grateful for the
opportunities that I have had to travel and see different places. 10 years into my aviation journey I still am
consistently challenged and stretched by my job.
There is something different every day. The return on my investment has been far beyond what I
expected when I started.
